[Book List]  

PLEASE NOTE: All bidding for the auction currently underway
at our new website at www.virtualjudaica.com/

Bidding Information
Lot #    10598
Auction End Date    5/24/2005 12:41:00 PM (mm/dd/yyyy)
Title Information
Title (English)    Arba'ah Turim
Title (Hebrew)    ארבעה טורים
Author    R. Jacob b. Asher (Rosh)
City    Frankfort am Main
Publisher    Johann Kelner
Publication Date    1712-15
Collection Information
Independent Item    This listing is an independent item not part of any collection
Description Information
   5 volumes, 311:200 mm., wide margins, usual age and damp staining, stamps, few marginal tears in initial ff. A very good copy bound in contemporary vellum, v. 2 in modern cloth boards, rubbed and split.
Paragraph 1    The R. Jacob Zevi Meklenburg copy with his stamp on title.

R. Jacob Zevi Meklenburg (1785–1865), rabbi and biblical commentator. R. Meklenburg was born in Inowroclaw, Poznania. Unwilling to enter the rabbinate, he engaged in business, but in 1831, after his business had failed, he accepted an invitation from the community of Koenigsberg to serve as their rabbi, and he remained there until his death. An opponent of religious reforms, he fought against the reformist ideas advocated in his community by Joseph Lewin Saalschuetz.

Ha-Ketav ve-ha-Kabbalah, R. Meklenburg's important commentary on the Pentateuch, in which the Author sought to demonstrate the conformity between the oral tradition and the written law. His commentary, which contains numerous original interpretations, was reprinted twice during his lifetime, with his additions and included a German translation of the text of the Pentateuch based on R. Meklenburg's commentary, by Jonah Kossmann. A fourth printing was begun some time before R. Meklenburg's death, but was interrupted because of differences between the publisher and the printers. In 1880, Abraham Berliner published a new edition with additional material from manuscripts left by the author.

R. Meklenburg was also the author of a commentary on the prayer book, Iyyun Tefillah, first published in 1857 with the siddur of R. Jacob Lorbeerbaum of Lissa; it, too, was reprinted several times. A number of rabbinic works carry introductory notes or approbations by R. Meklenburg.

   The four parts of the Tur with the notations of R. Abraham of Prague in one volume. The work is divided into four sections (Turim, "rows"; first complete edition, Piove di Sacco, 1475): Part I, Orah Hayyim, contains 697 chapters and deals with blessings, prayers, the Sabbath, festivals, and fasts; Part II, Yoreh De'ah, 403 chapters on Issur ve-Hetter (ritual law), commencing with shehitah and terefot and ending with usury, idolatry, and mourning; Part III, Even ha-Ezer, 178 chapters on laws affecting women, particularly marriage, divorce, halizah, and ketubbah; Part IV, Hoshen Mishpat, 427 chapters on civil law and personal relations.

The arrangement of the book, its simple style, and its wealth of content, made it a basic work in Hebrew law, and opened a new era in the realm of halakhic codification. R. Jacob invariably quotes the text of the Talmud and its commentaries as well as the opinions of authorities who preceded him, and then lays down the halakhah, mainly following Maimonides and his own father. On questions of faith and belief, however, he does not hesitate expressly to oppose Maimonides. He was aware of the views of the Hasidei Ashkenaz, whose influence is discernible particularly in the Orah Hayyim. The excellence of the work soon led to its dissemination throughout the Diaspora. Its authority has been recognized and accepted by all Jewish scholars throughout the generations, many of whom (including R. Joseph Caro, R. Moses Isserles, R. Isaac Aboab, R. Jacob ibn Habib, R. Joel Sirkes, and R. Hayyim Benveniste) wrote commentaries on it, and made precis of it. When R. Caro wrote his major work, the Beit Yosef, he decided to "base it upon the Turim... because it contains most of the views of the posekim."

R. Jacob b. Asher (1270?–1340), was the son of R. Asher b. Jehiel (the Rosh), under whom he studied. In 1303 he accompanied his father from Germany to Toledo, where he lived in great poverty, shunning rabbinical office and devoting all his time to study. In his learning, he avoided prolixity and casuistry. Typical of his style is his first halakhic work, Sefer ha-Remazim, in which he gave the halakhic rulings deduced from his father's work, Ha-Asheri (under the title Kizzur Piskei ha-Rosh, Constantinople, 1515). R. Jacob's enduring fame rests upon his major work, the Arba'ah Turim, as a result of which, he is commonly referred to as "the Ba'al ha-Turim." Perceiving that "reasoning had become faulty, controversy had increased, opinions had multiplied, so that there is no halakhic ruling which is free from differences of opinion," he decided to compile a work to embrace all halakhot and customs incumbent upon the individual and the community.

Jacob also wrote a comprehensive commentary on the Pentateuch (Zolkiew, 1806), containing the best expositions of the peshat ("literal meaning") by earlier Bible commentators, such as Saadiah Gaon, Rashi, Abraham ibn Ezra, David Kimhi, and others, in particular abstracting "the straightforward explanations" from the commentary of Nahmanides and disregarding the kabbalistic ones, since "my soul has not entered its secret" (cf. Gen. 49:6). To the beginning of each section, he added "as a little appetizer, gematriot and explanations of the masorah, in order to attract the mind." Ironically, it was just these "appetizers" that were published (under the title Perush ha-Torah le-R. Ya'akov Ba'al ha-Turim (Constantinople, 1500 and 1514)) some three centuries before the main part of the work, and it was this portion only which was widely known for many generations.

R. Jacob neither served in any rabbinical post nor received any remuneration from the community but was involved in communal activities. He appended his signature to a sentence of death upon an informer (Judah b. Asher, Responsa Zikhron Yehudah (1846), no. 75). His ethical will to his children (first published Pressburg, 1885) reflects his high spiritual and cultural level. A late tradition, mentioned by H. J. D. Azulai, relates that Jacob set out for Erez Israel but died on the journey.

Paragraph 2    ... עם פירושי וחדושי ... ר' יואל סירקש ... >בית חדש< (טור חשן המשפט ... עם פירושי וחדושי ... בית ישראל אשר חיבר ... ר' יושע פלק כ"ץ ז"ל בן ... ר' אלכסנדרי הכהן ז"ל ... והוא הספר פרישה ודרישה) והוגה ... ע"י בעל המדפיס (בנימן וואלף בהר"ר אהרן אליעזר זצ"ל טורלך) ...

הסכמה: ר' שמואל כהן שאטין, פרנקפורט [דמיין], כז מנחם[-אב] תע"ב. - טור [ג] טור (א): אורח חיים, שנת ת'ו' ח'י'י'ם' [תע"ד]. [2], רצו דף. מעבר לשער דברי המגיה. כותב בין השאר: שכבר נגמרו הטור יורה דעה ואבן העזר. טור (ב): יורה דעה. [לפני תע"ד]. רעז דף. טור [ג]: אבן העזר. תע"ב. [1], קלט דף. טור [ד]: חשן המשפט עם שני הביאורים ... האחד ... בית חדש ... והשני ... בית ישראל (פרישה ודרישה) ... שקם אחד מדייני ק"ק פרנקפורט ... ר' בנימן וואלף והביא האור הגדול נגד פנינו ... והוסיף ... כמה הגהות ושארי מעלות ... עם כל מראה מקומות ... ועוד הוסיף ... בסוף הספר כללי דיני תפיסה מהגאון המחבר פרישה וד'רישה אשר לא היה לעולמים. לפרט כה ת'אמר ל'בית י'עקב ו'תגיד ל'בני ישראל [תע"ו]. חלק א-ב. חלק א: (סי' א-קעד). [2], רסז דף. חלק ב: (סי' קעה-תכו). [1], קך, קפז דף.

   CD-EPI 0136100; EJ; JE; Waxman, Literature, index.
Associated Images
2 Images (Click thumbnail to view full size image):
  Order   Image   Caption
  1   Click to view full size  
  2   Click to view full size  
Listing Classification
18th Century:    Checked
Germany:    Checked
Halacha:    Checked
Autographed:    Checked
Language:    Hebrew
Manuscript Type
Kind of Judaica